|
Being
out of action for a long time is not SET India chief
executive officer Kunal Dasgupta's style. In 2004,
he had quietly watched Star India launch Utsav as
a flanking channel while preparations were on to introduce
Star One for upscale audiences.
Then
he decided to strike. Towards the middle of last year,
he called Sri Adhikari Brothers Television Network
Ltd (SABTNL) vice chairman and managing director Markand
Adhikari to Sony India's office in Mumbai's western
suburb of Andheri for a long discussion. His interest:
to buy out Sab TV, a niche comedy channel.
Just
the kind of talk that Adhikari wanted to hear as at
that time it had been nigh on four years that he had
been scouting for a strategic investor. Exploratory
talks he had initiated with Sony, Zee Telefilms and
Star India during this period had thus far proved
futile.
"The
meeting was progressive. Both agreed to pursue the
talks," says a source familiar with the deal.
To
be honest, Dasgupta was not totally convinced that
buying Sab TV would be the right step. He believed
flanking channels wouldn't work in India's current
environment. Zee's El TV hadn't; neither had Star's
Utsav. Doubts in mind, he took the debate to SET India
chief operating officer NP Singh.
NOT
A FLANKING CHANNEL, A GROWTH OPPORTUNITY
Assurances came from Singh and both agreed that Sab
TV should not be seen as a flanking channel but as
an independent growth opportunity. A humour-centric
channel with a male skew audience base that would
widen Sony's bouquet, which already had AXN to tap
English-speaking (or more pertinently thinking) male
audiences.
At
the early stages of discussions itself, both companies
realised that the deal would fit in with their future
strategies. Says Singh, "Sony TV is seen as a
female and family-focussed channel. With Sab TV, we
will get a male-skewed audience in the Hindi heartland.
This would broadbase our offerings as Sab TV would
bring in new audiences to the network. We decided
to push the deal forward."
This suited Adhikari as well. He wanted to start a
Marathi and a current affairs and news channel. Freeing
himself from Sab TV was essential as it was pulling
down the profitability of SABTNL, a listed company.
Net profit slumped from Rs 85.40 million for the fiscal
ended 31 March 2002 to Rs 16.30 million in the year
ended 30 September 2004 (financial year for SABTNL
is now ended 30 September).
And
in any case Adhikari had been preparing the ground
for an investor to step in. On 31 May 2004, he officially
declared that the broadcasting division of SABTNL
would be transferred to a subsidiary company. The
market reacted favourably and the scrip which was
lying low at Rs 50, jumped to Rs 70 levels in June,
before starting to slide back.
"The
market was expecting something to happen, but we felt
it was still all in the air," says a senior executive
in a brokering firm.
TALKS
INITIALLY STALL ON VALUATION
Sony and SABTNL were locked in negotiations, but
Adhikari was contesting on valuation. He was also
more interested in Sony picking up equity in Sab TV
as it would add value to the company and the stock
would get a big boost. But Sony was clear: it wasn't
prepared to take a part stake participation. "We
were convinced right from the start that if we are
to do a deal, it had to be a total buy out,"
says Singh.
Adhikari
quickly understood that: to get a suitable suitor,
he had very little choice left. Star had already started
Utsav, a free-to-air channel run with old content,
while Zee Telefilms had a wide spectrum of channels
to address different audience segments. Smile TV from
Zee stable, in fact, was positioned directly against
Sab TV. "He was now willing to sell out Sab TV,
something which he didn't want to do a couple of years
back," says a source close to the company.
The
news first leaked on 2 September that Sony was in
an advanced stage of negotiations with SABTNL to acquire
a majority stake in SAB TV. And on 28 September, SET
and SABTNL entered into an understanding: Sony will
have the exclusive option to distribute Sab TV as
part of the One Alliance bouquet and to acquire an
equity stake in the broadcasting subsidiary.
Hearing this, the market responded with the scrip
jumping from Rs 70 to a high of Rs 115 during the
September-January period. The expectation was that
Sony would pick up stake in Sab TV or even do what
Star had done with Balaji Telefilms: a vertical integration
deal with the content production company. Only in
this case, the content company had a broadcasting
subsidiary arm as well.
"The
anticipation was that Sony would pick up a 51 per
cent stake in Sab TV," says a market analyst.
That
was nowhere near the truth. But Sony was not worried
about the value of the scrip going up as it was negotiating
to buy out only the hived off arm of SABTNL. And with
the signing of the memorandum of understanding (MoU),
it had blocked off other suitors.
Clearly,
the deal was on. Sony had appointed consulting firm
KPMG to carry out a due diligence. "KPMG did
the initial due diligence. But we drove the deal ourselves,"
says Singh.
Adhikari
initially wanted Sab TV to form part of the distribution
of One Alliance while pursuing the talks for stake
acquisition. But Sony made it clear that could happen
only after the deal was struck. "He wanted to
convert it into a pay channel and bring it under the
One Alliance bouquet. But we were convinced that we
would bring it under the One Alliance fold only after
acquiring it," says a source in SET India.
Valuation
was still to be agreed upon. Adhikari, according to
market speculation, was asking for a Rs 1.75 billion
valuation on the strength of the brand and the unique
positioning of the channel. Sony ruled that out, making
it clear that it would get into the deal at a much
lower cost. Neither companies, however, were willing
to talk about it.
So
what made Adhikari arrive at a settled price? Sony
sweetened the offer by including a content supply
contract. Adhikari started negotiating for a long
term deal which would assure business for his content
company.
In
January, the clouds had almost all disappeared. That
is when Adhikari announced the launch of a slew of
nine shows on Sab TV. "We were very close to
the deal at that stage. We had got the internal clearance
from the board. Only the document processing work
had to be closed," says Singh.
And
then on 14 March came the big news: that the Sab TV
brand and 1305 hours of library programmes (representing
20 per cent of over 6500 hours of library strength)
and related assets were being transferred to SET against
a total consideration of $13 million (Rs 570 million).
SABTNL would also execute a programming agreement
with SET India for content supply worth Rs 750 million
over a span of five years.
"The
content supply contract was part of the complete package
that we offered. It made sense for us as we wanted
to ensure that the continuity of the channel was maintained,"
says Singh.
What
made a conservative company like Sony Group act so
fast? In one word, distribution. The second bouquet
of SET-Discovery's One Alliance comprising channels
like MTV, Nick, Animax, Discovery Travel & Living,
and NDTV needed a push up. "Distribution was
a big reason for acquiring Sab TV. But we also see
potential in growing the channel's advertising revenues,"
says Singh.
Though
Sony executives would not admit it, a prime driver
for clearing the deal was also the price at which
Sab TV was acquired. Launching a new channel would
invite not only content issues but also the cost and
difficulty of getting it distributed.
SONY'S
SWEETENER FOR ADHIKARI - CONTENT SUPPLY CONTRACT
For Adhikari, the bait was a supply content contract
of Rs 750 million. This would mean an assured business
for five years. Besides, he could focus on getting
content across Doordarshan and other private satellite
broadcasters, as a build up from the platform provided
by SET India.
Sony's
immediate challenge is to grow in more audiences for
Sab TV. Already showing movies on weekends, Sony plans
to position Sab TV as a "humour and light entertainment"
channel without deviating from its male skew audience
base. Reality and game shows are also being lined
up, though a complete fix on the channel's programming
will be finalised in the next few months.
"We
will have a variety of entertainment shows. Our initial
programming focus will be on the 8-10 pm band. Gradually,
we will expand it to 11 pm," says Singh.
Sab TV will soon have a business head to pump up the
channel. The channel has already shifted to PanAmSat
10 and is being offered as part of One Alliance's
second pay bouquet. Says SET India executive vice
president of ad sales and revenue management Rohit
Gupta: "We have set ourselves aggressive targets.
We will leverage the network strength to make sure
that we realise the full revenue potential of the
channel."
Having
taken full control of Sab TV, it will now be the task
of SET India to make a success of it. "When we
did the valuation and acquired Sab TV, we looked at
it from a 3-5 year perspective. We will make the right
investments to make it work," says Singh.
|