|
And
so the great Indian election season has come to a
close with results that will have shocked even the
most ardent Congress supporter.
Election
results apart, the last two months have also been
polling season on the news channels and each one has
been at it with a vengeance. This opinion poll and
that exit poll and what have you poll threw up contrary
results that swung this way and that like a political
weathervane in the thick of a storm. Indeed what stuck
out like a sore thumb was that all the polls had one
thing in common: they were all way off the mark in
terms of the final outcome.
And
considering that all the poll pundits got egg in their
faces in last year's assembly elections to the four
states of Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, New Delhi and
Chattisgarh, it does say something about the value
of such admittedly mammoth and complex exercises.
The
situation as it stands is that Prannoy Roy's NDTV
has come out of all the hustings hustle bustle with
the most to crow about. Not because it got it right
but it got it less wrong than its rivals. Admittedly
though, there is an area where it can certainly claim
credit. And that is in that it was able to get a feel
of the way the political winds were blowing better
than any other news channel. Did the oodles of experience
he has gained covering at least four elections as
a psephologist-commentator help him get it more right
than the others? Probably.
And
what has the whole experience been like for the viewer?
One thing they did not get was clarity as to the outcome
of what is without doubt a landmark election exercise.
But there is no denying the whole exercise had huge
entertainment value. There was suspense, drama, emotions,
action. All the ingredients that go into making a
great story. And the news channels certainly told
it well. Though they did stretch the truth somewhat
in the telling.
And
even as the news channels wind down from what has
been a heady two months (the news focus baton changed
hands from the cricket field to the political arena),
indiantelevision.com has been thoroughly engrossed
throughout. Though there have been times when the
exercise verged on the silly, all-in-all it did point
to one fact - that when it comes to the news business,
Indians can take on the best.
The
clutch of news channels fared well in their election
debut. A point that came through was that despite
the myriad news channels all reporting on essentially
the same things, there were enough differentiators
in their individual approaches to preclude complaints
of clutter and conformity. All a far cry from the
charge levelled at the Hindi entertainment channels
this time last year (not so much now it must be admitted)
that they were all dishing out similarly undistinguished
fare.
There
were innovative satirical ways of making the elections
less dull fare going by the efforts of NDTV's Gustakhi
Maaf and Double Take, Star News' Poll
Kholl and Sahara TV's Dharti Pakad. A touch
of what has been done with cricket was attempted on
news television with little animated political cartoons
jumping around aping the somewhat farcical mannerisms
of the netas. The keyline of these efforts being to
make political television journalism fun, alive and
ever changing.
The
conclusion: Exit and opinion polls should carry a
statutory warning: "Willing suspension of disbelief
beneficial to health when viewing exit/opinion polls."
|