|
Two
years ago, the top brass of India 's numero uno media agency Mindshare,
huddled together in Lonavla's Fariyas Hotel. In the room, were Mindshare
MD South Asia Vikram Sakhuja, Group M CEO South Asia Ashutosh Srivastava
and his predecessor Andre Nair. The discussion centered around the
challenges that media agencies were facing, Mindshare's role in
the entire Group M scheme of things, and the road that the agency
should take. The brainstorming went on for hours and the result
was a gameplan strategy which is being rolled out now and changing
the very innards of Mindshare.(To know more about how Group
M the holding company of Mindshare is structured in India,click
here)
Hear
out what Sakhuja has to say what brought about the rethink on Mindshare.
Says he: "In this competitive environment, where dog eats dog,
and where everybody is undercutting their business, a client goes
where he gets it cheaper. This is only because they are still viewing
life from a media buying perspective. We discovered we were not
getting value for the services we were providing."
Clearly,
even the largest media agency understands that it cannot sit back
and relax. It has to constantly innovate and even re-engineer itself
to survive; which is the process that is on in Mindshare today.
Shedding its skin of that of a traditional media buying/planning
outfit, Sakhuja and his team are donning a garb which allows them
to transform the agency into one with a communications based approach.
"Fame
& Money, 20 by 6 and extending into non-traditional media is
what we decided to zoom in on," says Sakhuja.
The
catch-all phrase "fame and money" encompasses a philosophy
which espouses that Mindshare will get its clients brand recognition
at a cost effective price and give them a return on their investment
that will make them sing.
Explains
Sakhuja: "Most of the agencies are looked at as media buying
shops. We want to be known as more than media buying shops. We will
make out clients' brands famous and rich on the back of plans routed
on insight which activates the brand using content, touch points
and direct. Marketing is using communication to get consumers to
behave in a particular manner. All of this is wrapped up in the
ROI mode where one demystifies the science of media and brings in
accountability." (To know more about the Group M buying
process click here)
To
ensure this, Mindshare has woven its strategy around five basic
tenets or pillars which will help it attain the unit's avowed goal
of Fame & Money for its clients:
*
Insight: The communication plan will draw insights that will
underline consumer behavior, media consumption and accordingly,
sketch a solution that uses these angles, not restricting it only
to plans based on reach, frequency and ratings.
* Content:
The planning approach will bring in the activation platform ensuring
personification of the brand via brand-consumer experiences. This
activation would be done by using content and touch points in a
big way. Content could be in the form of films, serials, properties,
in-product placement.
* Touch
Points: Mindshare has listed eight touch points where a consumer
can be impacted - Home, On the move, Work, Education, Entertainment,
Lifestyle, Eating joints, and Shopping. According to Sakhuja, Mindshare
is geared up in the entertainment and education space, and the focus
today is on 'Shopping' and a division called D-mart has been set
up to beef up skills in this area.
* Direct
- Which entails the interactive digital route - SMS, Web,...
* Return
On Investment (ROI) - Working on the modeling which will tell
the client how their sales will grow.
So,
while 'Fame& Money' is Mindshare's new lingo, the vision is
called 20/6. The 20/6 vision stands for a guaranteed tangible return
of at least 20 per cent of the client's total marketing investment.
Once that is delivered, Mindshare opines that it would be fairly
entitled to a 6 per cent commission on that marketing investment.
Sakhuja
asserts, "We are telling our clients that they will be tangibly
growing their topline, reducing their costs and hence also growing
their bottom line not only by better rates but also by using numerous
other factors and elements. Hence, six per cent in this scenario
for the media agency is definitely not an unfair ask."
Apparently, clients who have been communicated this proposition
have taken well to it, as this would bring about ownership, accountability
and more importantly, Mindshare will be putting its money where
its mouth is.
|
New
Biz : 04'- 05'
|
|
Boots
Healthcare
|
|
HSBC
|
|
ICICI
Prudential
|
|
Apollo
Tyres
|
|
Motorola
|
|
Tata
Steel
|
|
Century
Plyboards
|
|
Indian
School of Business
|
|
PCI
|
|
Venkateshwaran
Hatcheries
|
|
Kingfisher
Airlines
|
|
Star
TV
|
|
SS
Music
|
|
Duke
Biscuit
|
|
DNA
|
|
Legrand
(India)
|
|
Vedant
Aliumanium
|
|
Gini
& Johny
|
In
keeping with its thinking that it cannot work below a certain margin,
the agency's management is jettisoning business that does not match
with that philosophy. Bajaj was one such account which sent a ripple
through the media market when Mindshare chose not to continue with
it.
"Bajaj was an account where they wanted us to work on a very
low commission and hence we resigned the business," say Ashutosh
Srivastava and Sakhuja. "The second reason being, sharing rates
with a media audit company. We feel it erodes our competitive advantage
in the market. Also, considering we have a third of the market with
us, we'd rather use our own bench marks than a media audit company
which also gets rates from everybody else."
Another
reason the agency chose to drop the account was because media owners
called up and told Mindshare's managers not to divulge the rates
the agency commanded from them if they wanted to continue getting
them. "We have our benchmarks and it hurts our business to
share rates. But the basic issue why we chose not to continue with
Bajaj was they wanted us to work on a low commission."
| Key
Accounts |
|
HLL
|
|
Pepsico Intl
|
|
Frito Lay
|
|
Pizza Hut
|
|
GSK
|
|
HSBC
|
|
ICICI Prudential
|
|
ICICI Mutual Funds
|
|
ICICI
Bank
|
|
Gillete
|
|
IBM
|
|
Ford
|
|
DTC
|
|
HPCL
|
|
Onida
|
|
UB
Group
|
|
Kingfisher Airlines
|
|
Godrej
|
|
Motorola
|
|
Castrol
|
|
Tata
Steel
|
|
Berger Paints
|
|
Star
TV
|
|
Nike
|
Mindshare
currently commands 23 per cent of the market with a total of 130
clients. Seventy per cent of the business comes from media only
clients. Mindshare currently has offices in Bangalore, Calcutta,
Chennai, Delhi, Bangalore and Mumbai. The Mumbai office is split
into units - Mindshare 1 & Mindshare 2 due to conflicting businesses.
Mindshare Fulcrum - which is Unilever's dedicated media unit has
two offices - Mumbai and Bangalore. (To know more about each
of Mindshare's offices its revenue pie click
here.)
A sub-brand
termed Motivator came into existence a year and a half ago. With
two offices located in Delhi & Mumbai, Motivator was formed
for clients who by and large have buying and planning implementation
needs. Hence, plans are simpler and do not delve into heavy analytics.
The current base of Motivator is 65 clients; the focus being productivity,
efficiencies and a horses-for-courses set up.
In
terms of its revenue split up, 60 per cent of Mindshare's revenue
comes from global businesses, 35 per cent from local businesses
and 15 per cent from the emerging non traditional mediums (NTM).
(Have
a look at what Mindshare's
clients and media
owners have to say.)
Explains
Sakhuja, "Although all of the three streams are on the growth
path, the engines of growth are more in the non traditional space.
Two years ago, the contribution in terms of revenue from non traditional
media (NTM) stood at 2 per cent, while today it accounts for a good
15 per cent."
In the NTM space, entertainment, modeling, digital and Touchpoints
(in that order) are revenue drivers. Mindshare states that it has
scaled up and made huge investments to support its work in the entire
communications arena.
"We
have made investments in a research called 3D, which is in the insight
area, where one can go much beyond the NRS' and the TGIS' into actually
having a single source data tracking brand relationships, consumer
psychographics and behaviors that will deliver a report on how to
deliver specifically for a brand."
He
adds that 3D modeling allows tracking of several thousand people
across 25 categories across brands. "We invest over Rs 10 million
every year to get this up and running. It makes eminent sense to
be able to offset that cost across a much larger set of clients."
 |
|
Mindshare
Fulcrum's award winning innovation
|
Similarly,
the agency has opened a separate unit for entertainment.
"We
have tied up with studios, distributors and exhibitors, music and
content owners. With each of them, we have built certain linkages
and got relationships going. Also, for a lot of these initiatives,
we have struck strategic alliances with specialists in different
areas," says Sakhuja.
Sakhuja
states that Mindshare's strength comes from its global clients,
adding that the agency has a fair collection of large blue chip
Indian clients as well. Industry estimates peg Mindshare's billings
at Rs 17,000 million. It has had a good run since the beginning
of 2004, pocketing a total of 30 clients from then till date; its
biggest win being HSBC, which is a global business. Other significant
wins in terms of spends were ICICI Prudential, HPCL, Tata Steel,
UB Group and Motorola. (Click here for Mindshare's award winning
Horlicks
Whizkids case study.)
An important factor that Sakhuja highlights that will help the agency
achieve its '20/6' and 'Fame & Money' vision is Mindshare's
strongly cemented global network.
"We're
probably the best global network in the world. Hence any multinational
client who has got interests outside India cannot get a better network.
In fact, in a number of cases, we find our network stronger that
the clients own network. If a client has a global brand vision which
has to be cascaded over several markets; we have a strong network
in India, Pakistan, Sri Lanka and Bangladesh where we can implement
the brief in a flash. Also the network extends to the rest of Asia."
He
pointed out that Mindshare has made heavy investments in building
the network. Moreover, global accounts and regional teams meet on
a regular basis. Says Sakhuja, "I spend 10 -15 per cent of
my time on some of our global businesses at a global forum where
we take these agendas and move them. The power of synergies comes
to bear in a big way in these things. And at times when we see our
clients trying to work their network to do the same things, I find
us faster and more synergised. Increasingly, global businesses are
seeing a value in all of this."
Scale
is an unmatchable advantage that Mindshare has being part of the
large megalith called the WPP group and Group M. With an array of
agencies right from the recent Mediacom to Maxus to MEC, Group M
the holding company, has almost 40 per cent of the market under
its belt.
States
Srivastava, "This is where we use our benchmark systems, when
one has 40 per cent of the market share and if the data is mined
intelligently, the power that one has to make decisions is immense,
and I think we are doing it very responsibly."
Sakhuja
adds that the agency has a strong bench strength, "We have
some serious talent, and when talent is scarce in the industry;
our top brass is very stable. We also have the bench strength which
other agencies don't have."

While
that might be true, Mindshare today faces the highest attrition
rate in the industry. And interestingly, most of them them quit
the industry.
Agrees
Sakhuja. "The reason for this is quite clear. Media professionals
who join us have to start with doing a lot of grunt work. Although
we have made some serious investments in the back end automation
to reduce this as far as possible, we are still not there yet. The
returns on the investment made are yet to come. "
Sakhuja
points out that the management has not done a very good job in showing
people good career paths. "
despite actually having very
good career opportunities; but these come in spurts," he says
"Today,
we offer career paths either in the GM route / entrepreneur route
- content, modeling/ functional skills in the area of buying, planning
and training related areas and being a part of the global account
teams which is an increasing trend - where global teams are formed
for MNC's."
He
adds: "The manpower planning side needs to move into a well
oiled segment. And although the plan and vision is there, the staff
is not seeing it."
Mindshare
seems to be losing all its people to either media owners or clients.
"By giving them a large 360 degree space bandwidth, Mindshare
for a lot of new entrants becomes a training ground hence become
hot recruits for clients."
"Also,
we also have to look into client continuity as clients don't like
disruptions in their business. We also need to ensure that our internal
shop has able hands as outside talent is also slow to come. Somewhere
along the way, with some concerted effort, things should fall into
place," Sakuja says with confidence.
As
an organization, the perception is that Mindshare is quite "uptight"
and the aim for the top management is clearly to loosen up. Says
a thoughtful Sakhuja, "Yes, we are quite uptight, considering
the pressures and deadlines. We do need to ease out and add a human
touch."
That
touch might well help him achieve the vision he has set for Mindshare.
|