Indiantelevision.com > Media, Advertising & Marketing Watch > Indian ad agencies fail to execute good ideas: Dabral

 
Indiantelevision.com's Media, Advertising, Marketing Watch
 
Indian ad agencies fail to execute good ideas: Dabral
 

Indiantelevision.com Team

(8 March 2008 6:00 pm)

 

MUMBAI: Indian ad agencies do not lack ideas, but they fail to properly execute those ideas, said Bates Asia chairman, India and regional executive creative director Sonal Dabral.

Dabral, who was reviewing ads on the occasion of the Advertising Club Bombay's Annual Ad Review 2008 on 7 March, emphasised the use of humour as a device in an ad and said, "The best we produce in India cannot be compared with the best of the world."

The ad review is an annual endeavour of the ad club to analyse the good, bad and ugly of Indian ads, and examine them vis-à-vis international masterpieces.

Dabral showed 8 Indian ads and reviewed them on the basis of script, casting, idea, execution, etc. Some of the ads he reviewed included ads of Nike, Fevicol, Radio Mirchi, Vodafone and Neo Sports.

During his presentation, Dabral also referred to the work of Jonathan Glazer, and showed his award-wining ad Surfer's Ultimate Wave for Guinness Beer.

The review was followed by a panel discussion moderated by CNBC TV18 features editor Anuradha Sengupta. Apart from Dabral, who represented the Indian ad industry, the other panelist was group CEO of Future Group Kishore Biyani.

Asked as to what marketers need to do to build brands, Biyani said, "Brands are ephemeral. Each brand has a lifetime. After a couple of decades, a brand changes in response to the kaleidoscopic market. For example, our brand Bare has evolved from jeans to casual. Perhaps Big Bazaar will also undergo a change in time."

Dabral, however, maintained that a brand retains its core values in spite of the market changes.

The panelists agreed that celebrities are overused in ads and that at times such ads fail to build a connect with the target group. Biyani also admitted that Future Group's association with Himesh Reshammiya did not work.

In his parting speech, Dabral said, "We should ignore national boundaries, and select the right persons for an ad. We need to treat an ad like a baby so that it enjoys a long, happy life. All we need is the right attitude both from the agency and from the client."

The event also witnessed the presence of a number of luminaries from the Indian ad industry including ad legend Alyque Padamsee, Prahlad Kakkar (of Genesis Films) and Piyush Pandey (South Asia executive chairman, O&M).

The triumvirate was felicitated by the event's prime sponsor Xerox India, whose director of production systems group Vipin Tuteja used the occasion to unveil Wacky Talky 2008, a book that will feature stories from the ad fraternity.

 

 
Go to Top
Click for MAM Stories Archives
 
Also Read: