| The
meeting held at the conference hall of the Press Information Bureau saw much heat
over the issue, as news channel representatives said that existing laws are sufficient
to deal with the issues in hand, whether of privacy, indecency or violence.
Present at the
meeting from among the broadcasters were industry seniors Prabhu Chawla (TV Today),
Chintamani Rao and Rohit Bansal (India TV), Asutosh (IBN 7) and Arvind Mohan (India
Media Group), among others. The
government was represented by senior information and broadcasting (I&B) officials
including secretary Asha Swarup, director Prawin Kumar, and joint secretary Zohra
Chatterjee. The
channels held that the industry had its own code and would apply that as a self-regulatory
measure, and that the proposed Broadcasting Regulatory Authority of India could
restrict itself to regulating carriage, not content. The
broadcasters held that they have existing redressal measures, and people who found
anything objectionable could post the complaints on the websites of the news channels,
or even take them to court. The
news channels have told the ministry that they "shall deal with the issues"
and explain their "stand to the courts." The
channels pointed out to the provision mooted in the draft code that in case of
a dispute between the editor in chief of a channel and the content auditor, the
latter would notify the matter to the central government. This was clearly the
first step towards backdoor entry of censorship. Meanwhile,
Chatterjee made a presentation of the draft amended Broadcast Bill, which showed
that the government had diluted some of the provisions as per the comments received
so far. One
of the key amendments made so far is that the provision of the government taking
over any private channel in the public interest has been clarified and watered
down to say that this could be done only in the case of war or external aggression. This
precludes any repeat of the Emergency in the broadcast space in the future, sources
said. Attempts
to get a response on this from the ministry failed as the officials, including
those who had attended the morning meeting with the broadcasters, were in a lengthy
meeting with I&B minister Priya Ranjan Dasmunshi. |